Horse Slaughter in the US – What is the Solution?

You might be on one side or the other of the horse slaughter issue in the US – or perhaps at this time you are uniformed and/or undecided.  Here are some facts and an abbreviated timeline. Feel free to leave your suggestions for solutions here or on Facebook.

The slaughter of horses has never been illegal in the US at the Federal level. However, it has been illegal in California since 1998.

In 2005 legislation removed funding for the inspection of horses slaughtered for meat which essentially put the the horse slaughter plants out of business.

H. R. 2744—45
SEC. 794. Effective 120 days after the date of enactment of this Act, none of the funds made available in this Act may be used to pay the salaries or expenses of personnel to inspect horses under section 3 of the Federal Meat inspection Act (21 U.S.C. 603) or under the guidelines issued under section 903 the Federal Agriculture Improvement and Reform Act of 1996 (7 U.S.C. 1901 note; Public Law 104–127).

In 2007, the last operating horse slaughter house (in Illinois) closed.

Since then statistics show that just as many or more horses were slaughtered each year, the difference being that they were hauled to Canadian or Mexican slaughter houses.

In November 2011 legislation was passed that allows the USDA to once again fund inspectors of plants that slaughter horses, so there is the possibility that horse slaughter plants in the US could reopen.

With many unwanted horses in the US (a high percentage of those starving) and rescue and adoption programs filled to capacity (a few of those being the worst offenders regarding lack of care), what is the answer?

For more information:

Read The Unwanted Horse on the AVMA (American Veterinary Medical Association) website. You’ll find some very interesting and detailed Q&As there.

The American Association of Equine Practitioners also has some informative articles on their site, namely

The Unwanted Horse in the US

The AAEP Perspective on HR 503

We horseowners can agree on one thing:

None of us want horses to suffer, whether from neglect or malnourishment by irresponsible horse owners or by inhumane treatment when traveling or being euthanized.

What are some positive solutions to this controversial and complex problem?

Read Full Post »

Horse Care – When to Put a Horse Down

Hi Cherry,

I’ve read a lot of your articles related to my horse issues but can’t seem to
find my answer to this one.

We have an older appy gelding who was given to us.  We had bought a younger NSH gelding and this horse was his best buddy, so we took him too.  At the time we were told he was 17, but our vet said, no well into his 20’s.  This really didn’t bother me because I’ve know many horses that were useful at older ages.  I thought he would be good for my girls to learn to ride on. Unfortunately, he has some medical issues, and they are rapidly increasing.
He has laminitis issues in his hooves.  He has had abscesses in two, both
front and back.  He has DSLD. He has arthritis. He tends to be aggressive to
our other horses, all except his buddy the NSH.
In January we began Natural trimming with a trained trimmer.  She felt that it would be cruel to continue riding him, so he as been unridden since
December.  Our vet hasn’t really mentioned it, but said that eventually
there will come the time to put him down.

I’m wondering how to determine that time.  My fear is that he is in pain.
Currently he is on Bute for the arthritis to help with the pain and
swelling.  I had hoped that we would be in a position to have a pasture by
now as we plan to move, but that may be put off for another year.  With a
pasture I would simply let him live out his days, doing what he wants.  This
really isn’t an issue about his unusability, but his pain level and since it
is difficult to tell, I’m at a loss as to the right time.  Any insight would
be helpful.

Thanks, Patty

Hi Patty,

It is a difficult decision that most horse owners eventually have to face one day. The tough part is taking on the responsibility of making that decision, but ultimately the person who is the caretaker of the horse, usually the owner or owners, need to come to terms with what is best for the horse. We have to put our emotions aside and choose what is most humane for the horse. It is good you are thinking about it now while the horse is not in crisis – sometimes an emergency adds to the already difficult emotional decision.

Sometimes it is more difficult to decide what is best when others weigh in on the decision: co-owner, child, veterinarian………each person has their own view of that point where a horse no longer is comfortable. It sounds like you are the main person making this decision. If so, it will help if you step back and look at the big picture – how the horse was at his best and how he is now and if his current condition is full of more negatives than positives.

We horseowners seem to have a common dream in mind for our horses – we picture them “living out their days” on a nice pasture. Turnout is usually a good thing. But if a horse is laminitic and/or arthritic, turning him out on pasture (with grazing) might be unsuitable for the horse and contribute more to his lameness and discomfort. That same horse with a managed ration, therapeutic shoeing, a sand stall, and a suitable drug regimen might be more comfortable in confinement. Yet, would that be the right thing to do? In some cases yes, in others no.

Each person makes this decision based on different factors but to me the top
one is this. I ask myself, “Has the quality of life for this horse deteriorated to the point that he no longer can function normally in a comfortable manner?” If the answer is yes, then putting the horse down could be the most humane thing you can do for the horse. By function normally, I mean stand, eat, defecate, urinate, exercise, lay down, roll, socialize and all other things horse.

Other factors can enter in such as:

Do the treatment and management practices themselves add to the horse’s discomfort?
Does the drug treatment cause other problems?
Can the owner afford the full costs of care to keep the horse comfortable?

I hope something I’ve said has been helpful and I welcome further discussion on the topic.

Cherry Hill

Hi Cherry,

Thank you for your quick response.  We live in WA state, and the winters are long, wet and difficult for him.  He has perked up a bit with the warmer weather but I doubt he could make another winter.  He tends to stand a lot and his back legs creak when he moves.  He continually shifts his weight, I assume to alleviate the pain.  He does take enjoyment in some things, like eating and laying down/rolling.  It was really never my intention to send him out to pasture and forget about him.  Our new home would have a real barn, larger stalls and pasture turnout.  I’d hoped that he could spend his final days in a more idyllic situation.

Thanks again. Patty

Hi again Patty,

I could tell by your letter that you intended pasture turnout as only part of the retirement program for this horse. Because I planned to post this thread for others to read as well, I wanted to include that pasture turnout might not be in the best interest of some horses and some conditions.

You bring up an excellent point about the increasing discomfort to older horses during the cold, damp weather of winter. It is good you are looking ahead.

Thank you for your question and my best to you.

Cherry Hill

You might want to read about my good horses

Zinger and saying goodbye to her.

and

Sassy and saying goodbye to her.

Read Full Post »